We are now in Laos, after a full month of cycling (and briefly) riding the train through Viet Nam. It has been an incredibly long month, and subjective feeling based in part on the fact that every day we headed into new terrain, experiences, and ended up in a new town or city with new people and sights along the way. Every moment was a discovery, and except for our own personal habits, nothing was routine.
But having already been on the road through Thailand and Laos, we were able to process the experience of Viet Nam not only by recording it and discussing it with each other, but also by comparing it to what we had already seen (or endured) in the other countries.
For one thing, Vietnam is incredibly wealthy by any Cambodian standard (except for those in their government for whom no amount of money can satisfy...). There is electricity in even the smallest villages (that we saw) and phone lines, as opposed to people running the occasional TV, or their lightbulbs off of car or truck batteries. The food was also quite good, and the tap water safe to drink--which means that the ice was safe and allowed us to consume cold drinks on hot days.
Besides the mundane considerations of the cyclist (food, cold drinks, road conditions, weather, etc.) we have, for the entire trip, been especially sensitive to what we perceive to be the status or standing of women. We were incredibly heartened by what we saw.
Women comprise a huge section of the labor force, working on road and construction crews, working the fields alongside the men, and running many of the restaurants and shops throughout the country. This is in part, a consequence of the "American War" in the same way that Rosie the Riveter helped transform the labor force in America during WWII. (A brief aside: I want to mention very quickly that despite my bringing the issue up with nearly every Viet person that could speak passable English, I never heard any word at all of condemnation or even dislike of America. By all accounts, they say that the war is over, in the past, and there is no reason whatsoever to dwell on it. And they have every reason to dwell. The country still is pocked with bomb craters and victims, and yet their generosity of spirit is utterly amazing and, to me, bewildering).
When we were granted an opportunity to meet with the Quebec department of the global non-profit Oxfam to discuss issues of gender and trafficking in Viet Nam, I for one, was pretty happy to know that we wouldn't be going through the gloomy scenarios that haunt countries like Thailand and Cambodia. Have I mentioned yet how ignorant I am? It turns out that the picture is not quite so Rosie!
Project coordinator Kim Anh and gender specialist Carole Marsolais spent an afternoon with us explaining what is going on in Viet Nam and what Oxfam-Quebec is doing to stop it. Domestic violence is a major issue here, as is human trafficking. Before I go into their response and the nature of trafficking in VN, I think that it is high time that a definition of the problem be introduced:
The United Nations definition of human trafficking is “The recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons, by means of the threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability or of the giving or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having control over another person, for the purpose of exploitation"If you'll permit me to briefly quote from the UN's Economic and Social Comission for Asia's website, I think that some info is relevant. Bear with me:
The Asia Pacific region is seen as the most vulnerable region for trafficking because of its huge population pyramid, growing urbanization, and extensive poverty. Trafficking is a violation of human rights. Victims of trafficking suffer from physical and mental abuse and social stigmatization. They become isolated, losing ties with their former lives and families. At the societal level, trafficking undermines development efforts and raises social and health costs. The ongoing abuses of human rights and the growing social and economic inequality within and between countries has led to an environment in which many women have few choices and resources, and are thus vulnerable to being lured, mislead or forced into being trafficked. Women who are most vulnerable to being trafficked are those aged 10-35 and who are impoverished, uneducated or from indigenous, ethnic minority, rural or refugee groups. Such women often lack access to education and meaningful employment opportunities. Harmful cultural and customary practices also perpetuate discriminatory and violent practices that further diminish women's opportunities and lead to further marginalization and commodification. Promoting gender equality through the elimination of gender discrimination and gender-based violence will enhance the dignity and human rights of women and girls and prevent their being trafficked.
The above information is, in short, what Carole and Anh discussed with Jacob and me. Oxfam's approach has been to work with the police and train them in dealing with these new problems by helping them to understand what trafficking is (this is an issue which is critical in America, where many Mexican women that are arrested in whorehouses are treated as illegal aliens, when in fact they are victims of trafficking!). Also Oxfam seeks to provide vocational training to women that are at risk of being trafficked. Giving women a means of making a living is a surefire way to help them avoid the dangers of leaving home to unknown areas out of desperation for money. Former trafficking victims are often stigmatized for having become victims of trafficking, and so because of their own embarassment, or to spare their family the shame of having them around, they can not return to their own villages. Oxfam helps these women learn new trades.
I realize that I am covering quite a bit of ground here, and so I want to backtrack a few times, or at the very least provide some anecdotes. If there is anything that you are interested in learning about, post a comment to the blog and I will address it.
One issue is "How do these women get trafficked?" It is a good question but it varies depending on the situation. One woman that has been helped by Oxfam was tricked by her best friend into going to China to accept a job. She was forced to marry an abusive man, and had to spend 10 years with him before she could escape. Other times the cause is more indirect. Vietnamese people are hired as agents to recruit people for jobs in China. These recruiters have no idea that the people they recruit are going to be forced to do certain types of work. The recruiters themselves are unwitting pawns.
Another question is "How does one cross a border against one's own will? Aren't there guards?" It turns out that much of the border crossing is done through the jungle where there are no guards. Also there is often collusion between corrupt border officials and traffickers.
Also: "What are the victims forced to do?" This depends on what there is a need for. Many of those trafficked from Vietnam into Cambodia are forced to work as prostitutes because of the Cambodian preference for light-skinned women. A huge factor in trafficking in Viet Nam is that China's One-Child law led to widespread abortions of female fetuses (families want a son that will take care of them when they get old, not a daughter that they will have to give away). Accordingly, there are upwards of 135 Chinese men for every 100 Chinese women, and the trafficking of Vietnamese women (often forced to marry old, handicapped, abusive, or retarded Chinese men) has been a response to this shortage.
So, there's a picture of trafficking in Viet Nam, now what is being done to stop it!
The people at Oxfam generously introduced us to one of the programs that they help fund, the Vietnam Handicraft Village Research and Promotion Center (
www.hrpc.com.vn). We were shown around a project of this organiztion by its charming and very bright Development Manager, Nguyen Bao Thoa. (Once again, frustratingly, let me fill in some background: There is a Women's League of Viet Nam that has a total of 10 million members. VN has a total population of 80 million. So there is a strong presence of this union in the country and it has facilities in all parts of the country in correspondence with the political organization of Vietnam, from National level to Provincial, Municipal and Community.) Ms. Nguyen took us to the community center of the Women's League on the outskirts of Hanoi where we met with the chairwoman for the Community League and the Municipal League. At this center, the League has donated space to the HRPC, which has filled the rooms with looms and runs classes teaching former victims of trafficking and those who are at risk of being trafficked how to make beautiful bamboo scrolls and mats. There are pictures of us at this facility on our Shutterfly site (
http://tourforequality.shutterfly.com).
We spent a delightful afternoon visiting the facility and speaking with the chairwomen. Jacob and I were shocked to find that there was a problem with equality in a country with such a powerful women's league. The chairwomen informed us that though women work as hard as the men, there is very little sense of gender equality. For example, a husband and wife may go out to the field together in the morning at the same time and return at the same time, but then it is the woman's job to clean, cook, and take care of the children.
"What happens if the woman is sick?" Jacob asked, shocked.
"She calls her sister and her sister has to do it," they answered, laughing at our shock.
Fundamentally, the issues in Viet Nam, as in the United States, come down to social attitudes. Women in both countries have proven themselves every bit as capable as men of doing serious and demanding work. But in both countries, women continue to suffer from a social attitude that while there is parity in work out of the house, insider the house the man needn't exert any effort. This, the chairwoman of the municipality, Ms. Be, expressed as the greatest challenge facing Viet Nam today.
Obvioulsy there are other challenges as well. Viet Nam is just beginning to come to terms with domestic violence. In the past it had always been a hush-hush issue, but now, through the efforts of international and local non-profits, that attitude is changing. Broken bones and blood are now not considered the only evidence of abuse.
Mrs. Nguyen recently prepared a commercial for television that discusses the relationship between STD's (which the government is trying to eradicate) with sexual abuse. The government has prevented this commercial from airing, because it does not want to admit, or discuss, the existence of sexual abuse.
This blog is long and if you have read it to this point I thank you. I feel a bit swarmed under myself at the conversations and experiences of that day and all of the days that have preceeded it. What I can offer as a final note is that organizations like the HRPC and Oxfam-Quebec are having a real and powerful effect on the tremendous social problems that are emerging as a result of the global economy and the breakdown of traditional borders. The products of globalization: cheaper products of better quality in our kitchens, offices, and streets is at the same time rending the fabric of traditional and sustainable societies halfway across the globe. As quickly as pimps and traffickers step in to exploit this breach, dedicated and intelligent people like the HRPC and Oxfam-Quebec are also stepping in and are making our new world safer and more humane. They deserve our thanks, our admiration and our support.